GET 5% OFF YOUR ONLINE ORDER • ONLINE ONLY
(845) 278-4500
2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509
Open: 10:30 AM - 8:45 PM
5 Brothers Pizza & Pasta Restaurant

Authentic Italian Pizza & Pasta

Fresh ingredients, family recipes, and authentic flavors made with love in Brewster, NY.

View Full Menu Start Order

House Favorites

Delivery & Pickup

40-55 min delivery • 15-30 min pickup
$25 minimum • $2 delivery fee

Payment Options

Credit Cards Accepted
5% Discount for Online Orders

Catering Available

Full catering menu for events
Half trays feed 8-10, Full trays feed 15

Our Story

5 Brothers Pizza & Pasta has been a cornerstone of the Brewster community since 2017. Located at 2505 Carmel Ave, we're dedicated to serving authentic Italian cuisine made with fresh ingredients and time-honored family recipes.

From our famous Family Chicken Dinner Special to our authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, every dish is prepared with the same care and attention we would give our own family. That's the 5 Brothers difference.

Partnered with Slice to bring you convenient online ordering while supporting local businesses. Try the food and see why we've remained popular with locals for years!